Quick answer: Overstaying your leave is a serious matter, but it does not automatically justify the harshest penalty. On 16 November 2026 the Supreme Court reinstated a CRPF constable who had been removed from service for overstaying his leave by 99 days. He said he had been ill with hepatitis. The court held that unauthorised absence is not always wilful absence, and called the removal "grossly disproportionate". It ordered his reinstatement with 50% back wages.
What happened
The case is Mithilesh Kumar Pathak v. Union of India (reported as 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 1156), decided by Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh.
According to the judgment and reports by LiveLaw and Law Trend:
- Pathak, a constable in the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), was on leave at his village in Munger district, Bihar. He said he fell ill in October 2000 and was treated for infective hepatitis by a local doctor.
- He reported back on 19 January 2001, 99 days after his leave ended. He had not replied to two registered letters asking him to report.
- A departmental inquiry found unauthorised absence and disobedience proved, and he was removed from service on 29 March 2001.
- He produced prescriptions, pathology reports, medicine bills and a fitness certificate. These were rejected, mainly because they had no patient registration number, the treatment was private, and the papers appeared to be written with the same pen. Reports say the documents were never checked with the doctor or the pharmacy.
- A single judge of the Patna High Court set aside the removal in 2007. A Division Bench reversed that in 2010, saying the single judge had re-weighed the evidence.
- The Supreme Court set aside the Division Bench ruling and restored the single judge's order – about 25 years after the removal.
The law: absence, wilfulness and proportionality
Most service rules treat unauthorised absence (staying away without sanctioned leave) as misconduct. But courts have long said there is a difference:
- Unauthorised absence simply means you were away without permission.
- Wilful absence means you chose to stay away when you could have reported.
The Supreme Court made this point earlier in Krushnakant B. Parmar v. Union of India (2012): if absence is caused by circumstances beyond the employee's control, such as illness, it may not be wilful, and the disciplinary authority has to look at that question.
In Pathak's case the court found that the rejection of his medical papers rested on guesswork rather than evidence. Even after taking into account his earlier overstays (reported as 71 days in 1994 and 175 days in 1999) and his failure to keep in touch, it held that removal was grossly disproportionate on these facts.
Proportionality is the key idea. Courts usually do not re-decide the evidence in a departmental inquiry. But they can step in when a penalty is so harsh that it shocks the conscience, or when a finding is based on no real evidence.
What the court ordered
| Issue | Supreme Court's decision |
|---|---|
| Removal from service (2001) | Set aside |
| Reinstatement | Immediate |
| Back wages | 50%, from removal to reinstatement |
| Other benefits | All consequential benefits |
| High Court Division Bench ruling (2010) | Set aside; single judge's 2007 order restored |
What it means for employees
The ruling does not mean any absence is excused once you cite illness. Reports stress that it turns on the evidence and the facts of this case. But it gives employees – especially in government jobs and uniformed forces – some useful points:
- Inform your employer early. Pathak's failure to reply to the letters counted against him. A short message or letter with a medical certificate, sent as soon as you can, matters.
- Keep proper medical records: prescriptions, test reports, bills, and a fitness certificate when you rejoin. Registration numbers and hospital records make them harder to doubt.
- Ask the inquiry to verify your papers with the doctor or pharmacy if they are questioned.
- Challenge a disproportionate penalty. You can appeal within the department, then go to the Central Administrative Tribunal (central government staff), a State tribunal, or the High Court. CRPF and other armed police staff usually go to the High Court.
- Private-sector employees are covered by their contract, standing orders and labour laws, but the same idea of fairness and proportionality often applies in labour courts.
Sources
- Mithilesh Kumar Pathak v. Union of India, Supreme Court of India, judgment dated 16 November 2026 (2026 INSC 1219; copy on Indian Kanoon)
- LiveLaw, "'Grossly Disproportionate': Supreme Court Reinstates CRPF Constable Removed For 99-Day Overstay Of Leave" (November 2026)
- Law Trend and LawChakra reports on the judgment (November 2026)
- Krushnakant B. Parmar v. Union of India, Supreme Court of India (2012)
How Nevo Legal can help
If you are facing a departmental inquiry or have been dismissed or removed from your job, you can talk to a lawyer about labour and service issues. For other recent service-law rulings, read why gratuity can't be withheld over an appeal against acquittal and whether compulsory retirement is a punishment.
Can I be dismissed for overstaying my leave?
It is misconduct under most service rules and can lead to a penalty. But the penalty must be proportionate, and absence caused by genuine illness may not be wilful.
Is a private doctor's certificate enough?
It can be. In this case the Supreme Court said rejecting the papers only because the treatment was private, without checking them, was guesswork.
Will I get full back wages if I am reinstated?
Not always. Here the court awarded 50% back wages, taking the employee's own lapses into account.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For advice on your situation, speak to an expert.