+91 83300 68355 100% online legal services across India
Legal Updates

Can Recruitment Rules Be Changed Midway? Supreme Court Upholds a Written Test Added Later

Can a written exam be added after a government job advertisement? Supreme Court upholds Nagaland constable test – what candidates can and can't challenge.

A candidate filling an exam answer sheet – Supreme Court ruling on recruitment rules changed midway
Photo by Nguyen Dang Hoang Nhu on Unsplash

Quick answer: The "rules of the game" in a government recruitment cannot be changed freely once it has begun – but a change is allowed if the recruitment rules permit it and it is fair and applied equally to everyone. On 16 November 2026 the Supreme Court used that test to uphold a written examination added after the advertisement in the Nagaland Excise Constable recruitment. The rules provided for selection by "competitive examination/selection", so the test was within them.

What happened

The case is T. Akon Phom and Others v. State of Nagaland (2026 INSC 1211; 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 1162). According to the judgment and reports by LiveLaw, Deccan Herald and Morung Express:

  • In April 2025, Nagaland's Excise Department advertised Excise Constable posts (40, later raised to 46). The advertisement provided for a physical test and a viva-voce (interview).
  • A corrigendum dated 4 June 2025 added a written examination of 100 marks. The viva carried 12 marks.
  • The State said 11,521 applications came in; 5,985 candidates took the physical test and 2,297 qualified for the next stage.
  • Some candidates challenged the change. A single judge of the Gauhati High Court (Kohima Bench) quashed the corrigendum in October 2025.
  • A Division Bench reversed that on 23 June 2026. The final list of 46 selected candidates was notified on 29 June 2026.
  • The Supreme Court dismissed the candidates' appeal.

Why the court upheld the written test

As reported, the Supreme Court held that:

  • Rule 5(i)(a) of the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999 provides for direct recruitment through "competitive examination/selection". A written test fits within that, so it did not go beyond the rules.
  • Where the rules do not lay down a detailed method, the recruiting authority has discretion to decide how to test candidates.
  • A written test gives an objective, common basis for comparing candidates, unlike an interview, which is more subjective.
  • The test did not become arbitrary just because it was added after the advertisement, or because it carried more marks than the viva. No prejudice to the candidates was shown.

The law: the "rules of the game" principle

The leading case is the Constitution Bench ruling in Tej Prakash Pathak v. Rajasthan High Court (7 November 2024). In short:

  • Once a recruitment process starts, the eligibility criteria cannot be changed midway unless the rules allow it.
  • The selection procedure can be changed only if the rules or the advertisement allow it, and the change must pass the test of Article 14 of the Constitution – it must be transparent, non-discriminatory and not arbitrary.
  • In that case, a 75% cut-off introduced after the written test was the kind of change in issue.

That is why recruitment cases turn on the exact wording of the rules. In an earlier case about Bihar Public Service Commission assistant engineers, the Supreme Court struck down a midway change because it went against the rules. In the Nagaland case, the rules themselves allowed a competitive examination.

Change made after the advertisementLikely position
New eligibility condition (age, qualification)Generally not allowed unless the rules permit it
New stage or method permitted by the rules, applied to all, announced in advanceCan be upheld (Nagaland case)
New cut-off or criteria after candidates have already been testedOpen to challenge as arbitrary under Article 14
Change against the recruitment rulesCan be struck down

What it means for job candidates

  1. Read the recruitment rules, not just the advertisement. The rules decide what the recruiting body can change.
  2. Challenge early. Courts often refuse relief to candidates who take part in a process without objecting and complain only after failing. The High Court's Division Bench made this point in the Nagaland case.
  3. Show unfairness or prejudice. A change that applies equally to everyone and is announced in advance is harder to challenge than one aimed at a particular group, or made after results are known.
  4. Where to go: a writ petition in the High Court, or the Central/State Administrative Tribunal for posts that fall under it.

Sources

  • T. Akon Phom and Others v. State of Nagaland, Supreme Court of India, judgment dated 16 November 2026 (copy on Indian Kanoon)
  • LiveLaw, "Supreme Court Upholds Introduction Of Written Exam Midway Through Recruitment, Says It Ensures Objective Assessment" (November 2026)
  • Deccan Herald and Morung Express reports on the ruling (November 2026); Morung Express on the Gauhati High Court rulings (2025–2026)
  • Tej Prakash Pathak v. Rajasthan High Court, Constitution Bench, Supreme Court of India (7 November 2024)

How Nevo Legal can help

If a recruitment process you took part in was changed or cancelled, you can get legal advice on a writ petition or talk to a lawyer about service issues. Also read our explainer on whether you can be removed for overstaying leave due to illness.

Can a written exam be added after a job advertisement?

Yes, if the recruitment rules allow that kind of selection and the change is fair and applied to all candidates, as in this ruling.

Can eligibility criteria be changed midway?

Generally not, unless the rules allow it, according to the Constitution Bench in Tej Prakash Pathak (2024).

Can I challenge a recruitment after I took the exam?

It is harder. Courts often say candidates who took part without objecting cannot later challenge the process, unless it was clearly illegal.


This article is general information, not legal advice. For advice on your situation, speak to an expert.

Keep reading

More legal insights

Not sure which service you need?

Speak to a Nevo Legal expert. We will understand your requirement and recommend the right legal route – no obligation.